A matter of choice: Accept a safety plan or risk having your children taken away

In protecting children from abuse, the state has implemented “safety plans” that were challenged up to the U.S. Supreme Court. With the Court deciding on June 16 not to take the case, Erica L. Green and Sandi Villarreal look into how families who have lived under the plans deal with the emotional and financial strain of a system they say is forcing them to do greater injury to their children.

Aida Vallecillo tells how a safety plan affected her family

In early 2008, Aida Vallecillo and her family went through an intense investigation by the Illinois Department of Children and Family Services, accused of child abuse. She shares her experience of deciding whether to agree to a "safety plan" or have her children taken away. The child abuse allegations were determined to be unfounded.

A couple recounts having their children taken away

Interview with Mary and Tom Broderick whose family was separated for more than six weeks under a safety plan implemented by Illinois’ Department of Children and Family Services. The Brodericks talked with Erica L. Green about how an unfounded, three-month DCFS investigation still haunts their family five years later.

It can happen to insiders too: A psychologist recollects when DCFS intervened

Faith Kumar's two children were taken away from her and placed with relatives while she endured an investigation by the Illinois Department of Children and Family Services. She was only allowed supervised visitation. A year later, her case was ruled unfounded. Now, she and her children are trying to recuperate from the traumatic experience and move on with their lives. She talked with Sandi Villarreal about her experience.

Mary Broderick recalls the day a DCFS safety plan changed her life

I asked him if we don’t sign this, what happens? He said very plainly, ‘If you don’t sign this, we’re taking your kids into protective custody and they’ll be placed in foster care.’

View the history of the Dupuy case

It's been a long road for families and DCFS workers as they await a U.S. Supreme Court decision on whether it will consider the Dupuy case. View the history of the case here.

Review court documents concerning Dupuy case

The road to possible U.S. Supreme Court consideration has been a long one, dating back to the initial filing of Dupuy v. Samuels in 1997. Read some of the key court opinions and briefs in the case.

Families and DCFS state their cases in a nutshell

Affected families express their concerns about safety plans arranged by Illinois' Department of Children and Family Services, and DCFS answers back.

Badge

Family Abuse
For the People....around Chicago
Medill Reports on what's working and what's not.

Get the badge code:

Copy and paste to your site or blog

This site is a product of: Medill Reports: Chicago