Two mayoral candidates propose city public bank

By Dwight A. Weingarten
Medill Reports

While 12 of Chicago’s mayoral candidates addressed issues of housing, immigration, policing, among other critical issues at a packed forum, two zeroed in on an emerging but untested idea for a municipal public bank.

“We need to create a municipal bank that is from the community, for the community, which will give us low-interest loans in those [low-investment] neighborhoods to help with economic development,” said candidate Garry McCarthy, the former superintendent of the Chicago Police Department, speaking at the recent forum at the University of Illinois at Chicago.

Since 1919, the Bank of North Dakota has operated in conjunction with other financial institutions to provide assistance and promote commerce and industry in the state. Cities such as Los Angeles and San Francisco have explored the concept of a municipal public bank in the past several years, but the Bank of North Dakota offers the only U.S. model to examine.

Most of the Bank of North Dakota’s deposits come from state taxes and fees. The bank operates by providing agricultural, business, residential, and student loans and all bank profits are returned to the state.

Unlike most commercial banks, however, the bank is not insured by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC). The bank’s insurance comes from the faith and credit of the State of North Dakota.

The bank could even the playing field and overcome loan discrimination, according to McCarthy. He called intentional redlining the cause of “the social economic divide that is at the heart of what has happened in Chicago.” McCarthy offered the idea of a municipal bank as a potential remedy to “the social economic divide.”

Garry McCarthy, former superintendent of the Chicago Police Department, discussed the idea of a municipal bank as a remedy for historic inequities while Lori Lightfoot, former president of the Chicago Police Board looks on. Mr. McCarthy’s campaign did not respond to a request for further comment on the idea of a public bank at the time of submission. (Dwight A. Weingarten/MEDILL)

“[A public bank] is government getting into a business where there is already well-established competition,” said Michael Belsky, executive director of the Center for Municipal Finance at the Harris School of Public Policy at the University of Chicago.

“If you want banks to be good corporate citizens and invest in areas that are under-served then you can do that through regulations and incentives,” said Belsky, who expressed reservations about a public bank. Belsky served two terms as mayor of Highland Park from 2003 to 2011.

Amara Enyia, the director of the Austin Chamber of Commerce, supported McCarthy’s advocacy of the bank.

“I am glad that Garry McCarthy has adopted the hallmark of my economic platform, which is a public bank,” said Enyia, a member of a national network of public finance professionals that advocate for public banks in cities and states across the country.

At a separate event outlining her economic platform, Enyia said a public bank has the ability to be “truly transformative” for the city.

“Ultimately a public bank needs to be funded,” Belsky said in an interview. “If they lend out money and are not getting an adequate return then someone is going to have to subsidize them and it would have to be the taxpayers.”

Amara Enyia prepares for the forum next to Bill Daley, the brother of former Chicago mayor Richard M. Daley (in office: 1989-2011) and the son of former Chicago mayor Richard J. Daley (in office: 1955-1976). Enyia, who works in public finance, says the idea of a public bank has been on her radar for more than fifteen years. (Dwight A. Weingarten/MEDILL)

Deon Lucas, a co-founder of a collective real estate business E.G. Woode, acknowledges another reason why public banking is more challenging than traditional financing—it requires everyone’s voice to be heard.

“Cooperatives and democracy really hurt,” said Lucas, referencing the difficulties of organizing a collective business on a small-scale with multiple stakeholders at the decision-making table.

E.G. Woode includes all the businesses it helps to finance in the decision-making process and that can be a struggle, said Lucas. But “what came out of [the struggle] was more trust, more reliance, and more desire to push [the business] forward.”

For Enyia, the public bank is the centerpiece of her economic platform, but the idea stems from an underpinning of cultivating more civically engaged constituents across the city who participate in the decision-making process, including participatory budgeting at the ward-level.

“We, as a city, are in a critical moment where we realize that the past and the status-quo has simply not worked and led us to where we are,” said Enyia at the conclusion of a mayoral forum, hosted by the ACLU of Illinois. “What’s necessary is a new way of thinking and being.”

When asked if a public bank could be adapted to Chicago finances, given the structures in place, Enyia answered affirmatively.

“We should be a leader on this issue [of a public bank] and if we do it, it sets a trend for the rest of the country.”

Photo at top: The One Chicago for All Mayoral Forum at the University of Illinois at Chicago on Jan. 12 featured 12 of the mayoral candidates, but only two – Garry McCarthy and Amara Enyia – backed the idea of a city public bank. From left to right: Enyia, Bill Daley, Lori Lightfoot, McCarthy, Dorothy Brown, Susana Mendoza, Paul Vallas, Toni Preckwinkle, Willie Wilson, Gery Chico, John Kozlar, Bob Fioretti. (Dwight A. Weingarten/MEDILL)